Ping giving "General Failure" when pinging my Android phone from my Windows PC

Tailscale version: 1.34.1
Your operating system & version: Windows 11 21H2, Google Pixel 4a (Android 12, Rooted with Magisk)

The title pretty much explains it all lol.
Ping gives General Failure when pinging my Android phone from my Windows PC!

Tried:
Disabling firewall
tailscale ping pixel-4a (reports pong from pixel-4a (100.96.103.54) via [Public IP redacted]:30087 in 124ms)
tailscale ping --tsmp pixel-4a (reports pong from pixel-4a (100.96.103.54, 1) via TSMP in 104ms)